Article
Malvinas/Falklands Update:
ITLOS Considers Argentina’s Request to Halt Sea Lion as Sanctions Bill Advances
November 18, 2026

This alert follows our October 1, 2026 alert on Argentina’s offshore sanctions regime concerning the Malvinas/Falkland Islands (the “Islands”), available here. Since then, Argentina has advanced its position on two fronts:

  • Internationally, Argentina has asked the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea (“ITLOS”) to issue provisional measures requiring the United Kingdom to prevent new development drilling and the installation of production infrastructure for the Sea Lion project, including activities by persons under UK jurisdiction or control.  ITLOS has announced that it will deliver its order at noon Hamburg time on November 28, 2026.
  • Domestically, Argentina continues to pursue administrative and criminal enforcement under Law 26,659 and Decree 868/2026. The government has filed a criminal complaint extending to persons who “contracted, certified, facilitated,” or otherwise participated in Sea Lion-related activities. Meanwhile, the National Sovereignty Defense Bill — which, if enacted, would replace Law 26,659— has received a favorable committee report and it was placed on the agenda for a November 18 special session, but that session failed for lack of quorum. The bill may now be included on the agenda for next week’s session. If approved by the Chamber of Deputies, it will proceed to the Senate. Because the ordinary legislative session ends on November 30, the government would need to call an extraordinary session for the Senate to consider the bill thereafter.

These two tracks operate on different legal planes and create different risks. The ITLOS order will bind only Argentina and the United Kingdom, but depending on its terms, it could require the United Kingdom to halt or delay Sea Lion drilling and infrastructure work, disrupting the project’s timetable and the contracts that depend on it. Argentina’s domestic regime, by contrast, applies directly to companies and individuals and will continue regardless of what ITLOS decides. Contractors therefore face two distinct risks: commercial disruption of the Sea Lion project itself, and potential administrative and criminal exposure under Argentine law for participating in the project.

Contractors also featured prominently in the ITLOS proceedings, in two respects. First, the United Kingdom relied on them to answer Argentina’s criticism of the operators’ experience, telling the Tribunal that Navitas has engaged “world-leading contractors” that “will be the ones carrying out the relevant operations.” Second, the first measure Argentina requested targets exactly the work those contractors are engaged to perform, so they would be directly affected by any order restricting drilling or infrastructure installation.

Domestic Enforcement Now Targets Contractors and Logistics Providers

As described in our prior alert, Law 26,659 already reaches persons providing services to, or transacting with, unauthorized operators, and Decree 868/2026 provides for an expedited sanctions procedure with referral to criminal prosecutors. Two recent enforcement actions show how Argentina is applying that framework to suppliers.

  • The government’s criminal complaint expressly targets contractors. Argentina’s Foreign Minister has filed a criminal complaint under Law 26,659 against Navitas Petroleum Development & Production, Navitas Petroleum Atlantic, Navitas Petroleum LP, JHI Associates Inc., and Eco (Atlantic) Oil & Gas, together with related companies, directors, and representatives. The complaint asks prosecutors to open an investigation; it is not a charging decision or a court ruling, and the complaint itself states that it does not formulate a definitive accusation against specific persons. For context, in 2022, Argentina declared Navitas Petroleum LP’s activities in the Islands illegal and disqualified it from operating in Argentina for twenty years. An English version of this criminal complaint is available here.

The criminal complaint also reaches persons who participated in, authorized, contracted, certified, or facilitated Sea Lion-related activities, and it expressly includes logistics and transportation providers. It asks prosecutors to investigate potential customs and hazardous-waste offenses, criminal conspiracy (asociación ilícita), and money laundering. It also seeks international judicial cooperation and asset-preservation measures.

  • Logistics providers face demonstrated enforcement risk. Argentina has pursued Thales UK Limited over two allegedly unauthorized flights between Punta Arenas, Chile, and the Islands. In October, Argentina’s civil aviation authority filed a criminal complaint and sought confiscation of the aircraft. The case shows that enforcement may extend to air, maritime, customs, and transportation services, not only offshore drilling. This second criminal complaint remains undisclosed.

The Revised Bill: A Knowledge Standard, but Significant Exposure Remains

On October 27–28, the Chamber of Deputies’ National Defense, Criminal Legislation, and Foreign Affairs committees issued a majority report amending the National Sovereignty Defense Bill, the original version of which we summarized in our prior alert. Any measure approved by the Chamber would also require Senate approval. An English version of the revised bill is available here.

Supplier liability. The committee text would limit supplier liability to “essential and indispensable” goods or services, meaning those without which the prohibited activity could not proceed. It would also require proof that the supplier “knew or could not reasonably have been unaware” of the intended use. We expect knowledge could be established through circumstantial evidence.

The same standard would govern a new criminal offense punishable by two to seven years’ imprisonment, fines equivalent to 20,000 to 100,000 barrels of oil, and commercial disqualification.

Argentina sent formal warnings to Navitas and Rockhopper in September 2026 and recently disclosed that it sent more than 180 deterrent letters to companies linked to Sea Lion and their home States. Such notices, together with publicity surrounding the dispute, could support an argument that a supplier could not reasonably have been unaware of the intended use of its goods or services.

Other Provisions Relevant to Suppliers and Counterparties

  • Investment carve-outs. Individual shareholders holding 2 percent or less, and non-discretionary investment vehicles, would be excluded if they appoint no directors or supervisory officers.
  • Contracting ban. New contracts with persons listed on the public register of sanctioned or convicted parties would be prohibited, with fines of two to four times the benefit obtained — including 2,000 to 40,000 barrels when the benefit can't be determined.
  • Protection for good-faith counterparties. Counterparties whose contracts are terminated under the law would retain their claims, incur no liability to the sanctioned party, and rank ahead of the State’s claims for fines.
  • Claims bar. The sanctioned party, entities it controls or that act on its behalf, and assignees of their claims could not bring claims in Argentina arising from the termination or non-performance of contracts under the law, including claims for performance, damages, set-off, or enforcement of guarantees. The bill would declare these rules internationally mandatory, meaning Argentine courts would apply them regardless of the law the parties chose to govern their contract. The committee text no longer expressly refers to the recognition of foreign judgments or arbitral awards, but a sanctioned party seeking to enforce an award or judgment in Argentina should expect the bar to be raised against it.
  • Joint ventures. Sanctions against one participant would not affect other participants’ authorizations or incentive benefits, and the sanctioned participant could transfer its interest to an unrelated party during the wind-down period.
  • Anti-avoidance. Liability would survive mergers and reorganizations, including transactions completed outside Argentina.
  • Provincial participation. Because Argentina’s federal system leaves certain licensing and natural-resource powers with the provinces, the law’s consequences for provincial and municipal permits, authorizations, and benefits would apply only in provinces and municipalities that formally adhere to the law. Companies holding provincial authorizations should therefore monitor whether the relevant province adheres.
  • Enforcement authority. The Ministry of Foreign Affairs would administer the regime.

The ITLOS Proceedings

Argentina commenced arbitration against the United Kingdom under Annex VII of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (“UNCLOS”) on September 28. On October 13, it requested provisional measures from ITLOS under Article 290(5).

Argentina has asked ITLOS to require the United Kingdom to (i) prevent new Sea Lion development drilling and the installation of production infrastructure; (ii) refrain from using information obtained through exploration to Argentina’s detriment, which Argentina explained would cover transfers to third parties; (iii) refrain from conduct that prevents Argentina from complying with its own obligations under UNCLOS Articles 192 and 194 to protect and preserve the marine environment in the disputed area; and (iv) refrain from any other measure that could aggravate the dispute, including granting new exploitation authorizations. The United Kingdom has asked ITLOS to reject all of Argentina’s requests for provisional measures.

  • Jurisdiction. The United Kingdom argues that Argentina’s claims require resolution of the underlying territorial sovereignty dispute, which falls outside UNCLOS jurisdiction. Argentina responds that it does not ask either tribunal to decide sovereignty, and seeks only to preserve its asserted continental-shelf rights until the sovereignty dispute is resolved through the bilateral negotiations, with the Secretary-General’s good offices, called for by UN General Assembly resolutions.
  • Project schedule. The United Kingdom represented that development drilling will begin no earlier than March 21, 2027, with production no earlier than March 2028. Phase 1 contemplates eleven development wells.
  • Urgency and tribunal constitution. The United Kingdom argued that there is no urgency because the Annex VII tribunal is expected to be constituted by the end of 2026 or, at the latest, January 2027, well before drilling begins, and could then hear any provisional measures request itself. It also stated that no production license has been granted since 2009 and that the licensing regime is suspended, so that there is no risk of the new authorizations targeted by Argentina’s fourth requested measure. Argentina responded that, based on prior Annex VII cases, a newly constituted tribunal would not be able to function and decide such a request before drilling starts.
  • Consequences of suspension. Navitas CEO Ian Ramsay stated that “the Project would not survive a suspension” and that “[e]ven the shortest of suspensions ordered by ITLOS would have a terminal effect.” The United Kingdom explained that Sea Lion depends on interlocking operational and financing arrangements that cannot readily be paused and restarted.
  • Contractual and financial exposure. To rebut the claim that a suspension would be fatal, Argentina pointed to Navitas’s annual report, which caps Navitas’s liability for terminating the floating production, storage, and offloading vessel contract at US$109 million. The United Kingdom responded that this figure reflects a single obligation under one contract and is “the tip of the iceberg.” Rockhopper states that its sunk costs exceed US$1 billion. Argentina also cited Navitas’s US$1 billion political-risk insurance policy, which the United Kingdom said protects only the lenders’ debt repayment in the event of war and similar events.
  • Rig and preparatory activity. To show urgency, Argentina cited Noble’s fleet status report identifying the Noble Endeavour as beginning work in “South America” in January 2027 for an undisclosed operator, and described ongoing transportation of rigs and equipment as evidence that contractor activity is already underway and that drilling could begin before an Annex VII tribunal is able to act.

What the ITLOS Order Could Mean

Provisional measures would formally bind Argentina and the United Kingdom, not private companies. But an order substantially granting Argentina’s request could require the United Kingdom to prevent Sea Lion drilling and infrastructure work by licensees and contractors.

  • Measures substantially granted. Development drilling and infrastructure installation could be suspended, increasing the likelihood of disputes involving force majeure, illegality, sanctions, change in law, payment, guarantees, and termination.
  • Partial or modified measures. ITLOS could impose information-sharing, environmental, or non-aggravation obligations without stopping drilling. Contractors would need to monitor UK implementation measures and additional compliance requirements.
  • Request rejected. Sea Lion could proceed on its current timetable. Argentina could, however, submit a new request for provisional measures to the Annex VII tribunal under Article 290(1) once that tribunal is constituted, a possibility the United Kingdom itself contemplated at the hearing. Under any scenario, Argentina’s domestic sanctions and enforcement regime would continue independently.

Conclusion

The ITLOS proceedings create a significant near-term risk for Sea Lion that runs in parallel with, and independently of, the exposure created by Argentina’s domestic sanctions regime. The November 28 order could have immediate consequences for operators, contractors, financiers, and counterparties, while Argentina is likely to continue pursuing domestic enforcement and legislative reform regardless of the outcome.

King & Spalding will report on the ITLOS order and will continue monitoring Argentina’s National Sovereignty Defense Bill as it proceeds through Congress.

Explore King & Spalding
a group of ships in a port at night
Capabilities
Energy
a man in a hard hat and vest walking in front of a machine
Capabilities
Oil, Gas & Chemicals